Compare / putter
Live · checked today · 13 UK retailers tracked
Scotty Cameron MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter vs Scotty Cameron Phantom 12 Putter
Quick verdict
Checked daily across 13 UK retailers
Price and availability verdict
Scotty Cameron MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter is currently £679.95 used, while Scotty Cameron Phantom 12 Putter is currently £449. Against tracked history, Scotty Cameron MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter is at its lowest tracked price and Scotty Cameron Phantom 12 Putter is 50% above its lowest tracked price. Scotty Cameron MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter is currently available from 1 UK retailer, versus 12 for Scotty Cameron Phantom 12 Putter.
Scotty Cameron
MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter
£679.95 used No change at its low Buy £679.95 → at Replay GolfDeal intelligence
Should you buy now, or wait?
The Scotty Cameron MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter is at its lowest tracked price today. The Scotty Cameron Phantom 12 Putter has more room: its tracked low is £299.95.
Scotty Cameron · MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter
Not enough data yet
Today £679.95 · typical £1,099.95 · lowest £679.95
On sale 1 time in the last 3 months
Scotty Cameron · Phantom 12 Putter
Not enough data yet
Today £449 · typical £299.95 · lowest £299.95
Head to head
Category leaders, from the data on this page
- Cheapest new Phantom 12 £449 vs £679.95
- Closest to its tracked low MY Girl Fancy & Forever 0% above vs 50%
- Most retailers in stock Phantom 12 12 vs 1
Where to buy
13 UK retailers, checked daily
Price trajectory
How each has moved since we started tracking
Lowest tracked price per day, any condition. Caddence tracks both daily. Shaded spans are days we couldn’t collect prices — the lines break rather than guessing.
Scotty Cameron · MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter
↓ £420
since 9 April 2026
Lowest £679.95 on 18 August 2026
Scotty Cameron · Phantom 12 Putter
↑ £149.05
since 30 May 2026
Lowest £299.95 on 30 May 2026
New vs used
From used listings we track
Scotty Cameron · MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter
NEW £679.95
USED FROM £679.95
Availability by build
Which configurations are in stock right now
| Build | Scotty Cameron MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter | Scotty Cameron Phantom 12 Putter |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | — | 11 retailers · from £449 at Scottsdale Golf → |
| Used | 1 retailer · from £679.95 at Replay Golf → | — |
| Left-hand | — | 1 retailer · from £449 at Express Golf → |
Waiting for a better price?
Set a free alert and we’ll email you when either drops to your target.
Related putter comparisons
More head-to-head price checks
Common questions about the Scotty Cameron MY Girl Fancy & Forever Putter vs Scotty Cameron Phantom 12 Putter
Prices shown are the cheapest in-stock price per retailer tracked by Caddence, updated daily. Always confirm the final price on the retailer's site.